We were conjoin foran “ require The Expert ” academic term by Kevin Grazier(whose credits , in improver to Gravity , also admit stints at NASA and Battlestar Galactica ) . In response to a question bychulo333,on how to strike a compromise between scientific accuracy and good taradiddle - telling , Kevinshared his thoughts on the benefit of emphasizing both scientific discipline and fable in skill fiction :
https://gizmodo.com/ask-the-science-advisor-of-gravity-kevin-grazier-anyt-1444946378
There is ALWAYS a compromise between story and scientific discipline in a scientific discipline fiction or science - theme show . We ’re not doing documentaries , and the science should serve the report , not the other way around .
There was a tantrum in “ Battlestar Galactica ” where the prominent thou was plummet through the ambiance of a planet , launching fighters as it dropped , jump aside just before impact with the ground . The scene is a vast fan pet , even though there are many many expert exit with that setting . Who care when it ’s just so FRAKKING COOL ?
What discompose me , as a skill advisor OR a viewer , is when the skill is inaccurate and did not have to be . For me that go on progressively less . The gauze-like fact that a output chooses to use a skill advisor , entail that they already have a reasonably high dedication to scientific accuracy .
In one episode of “ Defiance ” last season ( episode 107 , “ Goodbye Blue Sky ” ) , our showrunner Kevin Murphy in reality bent over backwards to an dumbfounding degree until we found a science solution that made the news report work .
So it can be frustrating when there is reluctance on the production side to changing something obviously wrong , but I think that writers / producers / directors are ever - increasingly listening to the input of their skill advisors , showing that science and story often can roleplay in the same sandbox .
Image : nienora / Shutterstock
NASASci - FiSpace
Daily Newsletter
Get the best tech , science , and culture news show in your inbox daily .
News from the future , birth to your present .
Please pick out your desire newssheet and reconcile your email to upgrade your inbox .
You May Also Like
