A few weeks ago , we ask you to take a survey about whether Star Trek or Doctor Whohad cast your brain . We wanted to get it on whether there was any connection between being a fan of one of these shows and what your life history aspirations might be – as well as what career you nose up throw . Over 1600 people respond , and it turns out Doctor Who and Star Trek fans are n’t very differently - brain . Both shows inspire fans to have similar dream jobs , though not all of them manage to get those jobs when they raise up . We also discover what fans want most from the show . Find out more , and tick off out our awful information chart , below .
https://gizmodo.com/did-star-trek-or-doctor-who-mold-your-brain-381274
Overall Mindsets
The bedspread of occupations and breathing in for both Doctor Who and Star Trek fans is almost - indistinguishable ; what dissent , in fact , is the occupations and the aspiration themselves .
The number one dream of approximately 29 % of the 1,648 survey respondents is to work in science . Visual and Performing Arts take a close second , with 14 % of respondent wish to exercise in that area . After that , 11 % of respondent declared “ Other , ” and while most of those were either unsure of their vocation or unwilling to come in their Job in one of the broader categories , the most outspoken detail in the “ Other ” grouping denote their childhood regard to be cosmonaut . Both Star Trek and Doctor Who , then , breed aspiring stargazer , intellectuals , artists , actors , and people with careers too varied to define .
Where the lives of devotee actually end up is a slightly unlike matter . 23 % of respondents make for in Computers & Mathematics , even though less than 7 % aspired to that life history . Students are next — perhaps those 17 % of respondents are all budding scientists and thespians , though the majority paint a picture otherwise . 9 % of respondent specify their careers as Education , Museum Work , and Library Science ; only 5 % wanted to cultivate in that area as tike . Just under half of the aspiring visual and performing artists reach their dream , and only 2 % oeuvre in the wonk - kid - favorite vocation of Science .
While this is as much influenced by teacher , parent , mentors , locating , and salaries as it is any TV show , the crevasse between childhood dream and eventual careers is a relation feeling at how the need of the earth transform the aspiration of individual .
“ They are both studies of mankind : Star Trek is more about putting people into abstract situations and seeing what humanity emerge , while Doctor Who tends toward deciding what humanity should be introduce into an abstract situation . ”
“ I ’m a devotee of Star Trek for its optimism . I wish the idea that skill and engineering can be applied to solve our trouble . I like Doctor Who for its sense of marvel at the creation ’s complexity . ”
“ Star Trek represents a structured authority in exploration , while Doctor Who favors the “ mad genius inventor , ” an someone explore on their own . … Doctor Who does a better job of depicting what it is to be truly alien . Star Trek does a good caper of study what it mean to be rightfully human . ”
Age and Discovery
In the 13 - 19 and 30 - 39 age group , Doctor Who takes the track — in 20 - 29 , 40 - 49 , and 50 - 59 , Star Trek wins by a large margin . Over one-half of respondent in the latter three old age groups are Star Trek rooter , while in its field Doctor Who scrapes by with an average of 52 % . Of naturally , 77 % of survey respondents are from the United States , which means that older lover would face the difficult task of watch abroad television receiver to be Whovians .
New fans are arrive by the moment , however , to switch those numeral . 28 % of Dr. Who fans discovered the show less than 5 long time ago ; these fresh recruit no doubt owe their fandom to the vivify New Who . Star Trek ’s fan base of operations , according to these sight respondents , has develop only 2 % in the last 5 years , so it looks like Enterprise did n’t serve much .
Either way , do n’t get these termination depress you . I doubt the devoted fanbase — the 64 % of 15 - plus - twelvemonth MD Who buff and 81 % of those near - life Star Trek fans — is going anywhere anytime soon .
“ I was drawn to the Doctor because he always resolved battle using is head and rely little on brute force and violence . I be intimate the cerebral nature of it ! ”
“ What force me to Star Trek is Roddenberry ’s vision of a universe where the definition of what it means to be human is constantly exchange so that it ’s more inclusive . … I have major problems with the Doctor as a graphic symbol , because he ’s essentially undemocratic — this guy just goes around pop aliens on my behalf , but I have no say in it . ”
“ Star Trek … envisage a scientific , scholarly existence in a future where ( in general ) masses are nice to each other ; it inscribe ( sorta ) my arduous sci - fi urge . [ Doctor Who is ] lots of fun following the adventures of a magnetic , brilliant eccentric in a screwball world ; it scratches my Douglas Adams - ish fantastic sci - fi itch . ”
“ Trek tells the tale of events that happen to the great unwashed , but not so much what happens between people . ”
Watching the show
The Star Trek fanbase sure is a police force - abiding bunch : Of the 992 people who are fans of Star Trek ( 217 of them also lover of Doctor Who ) , 81 % watch the show when it airs and only 8 % snag it from the entanglement . Meanwhile , 48 % of the 873 who watch Doctor Who ( include , again , the 217 who also know Star Trek ) download their episodes from the internet — compare that to the 46 % who watch it on tv . Of course , this may have something to do with the fact that Doctor Who ’s overwhelming US fanbase does n’t feel like waiting for BBC America to show installment almost a year old . irrespective , there ’s got to be something here about the average Star Trek devotee ’s respect for the directives of the regime — and the Doctor Who fan ’s love of noncompliant risky venture .
Star Trek , however , does have more charm across the globe , propose either great exposure for American television or greater ingathering to people in wide-ranging guild . Star Trek ’s fan hail from 33 countries , while Doctor Who ’s live in 22 . There are fans of both shows in 12 apparently sci - fi - well-disposed country : the United States , the United Kingdom , Canada , Austrlia , New Zealand , China , Brazil , France , Italy , the Netherlands , Spain , and Trinidad & Tobago .
“ I was attracted to the misanthropic anti - establishment eccentric of the Doctor , and the unequalled betting odds of his dangerous undertaking — a unmarried somebody pitting wits against brawn , whereas Trek was always about the establishment , not the underdog . ”
“ The beauty of Star Trek is the betterment of humans through the quenchless need to screw more . [ The medico ] is a deserter , cruising around , finding trouble and making them correct with his vast knowledge and skills . ”
last Comments
There were quite a few problem with my study , and you all point them out when you hire it . A few lesson : my categories for occupations and aspirations were too broad , provenance might not be the most exact index of a person ’s internal identity , and it ’s impossible to quantify moral attitudes and sentiment on the world simply by asking about career aspiration . The tilt go on . I urge you to download my data mainsheet , conduct your own research , and draw in your own ending . As a science fiction fan , you should be well - suited to the undertaking !
In closing , I have to forget you with these two stories . Someone out there has the most awesome husband ever , and someone else should sense free to claim the most awing parents .
“ When I first fit my husband and demand for his number , he said he ’d give it to me if I knew who Davros was . I explained all about the Daleks to him , he gave me his issue , and , well , now we are marital . I guess I owe finding dead on target love to Doctor Who . ”
“ My parent met because of Original Star Trek . I was impregnate with it since before I was carry . I grow up being scuff to pattern and fan nightspot meetings , and learn an awesome lot about life through my mom ’s confidential stash of fanfiction . Although it ’s not my favorite show , I have a tremendous respect for it , because it really did made me into someone confident in her ‘ geekiness . ' ”
Charts by Stephanie Fox .
If you require to see all our data , you could downloadthis PDF .
Doctor WhoStar Trek
Daily Newsletter
Get the best tech , science , and culture news in your inbox day by day .
News from the future , present to your present tense .
You May Also Like
